Skip to main content

Errer Cards - Wrong Players


Everyone is familiar with cards showing the wrong player, but here are a few I rarely see mentioned.

If you know who Pete Mackanin is you know he's white. This 2006  Topps card #287 appears to me to be Lloyd McClendon.

This 1982 Fleer card #639 honors Len Barker's perfect game pitched. The problem is that Bo Diaz (pictured on the right) didn't catch the game, Ron Hassey did.

The following 1989 Topps card #37T of Bob Geren is actually a photo of Mike Fennell. Mike played minor league ball from 1982 - 1985 making it up to Double A. I believe Mike was a bullpen catcher for the Yankees at the time of the photo. Mike was born in Saratoga Springs, NY, played college ball here in Syracuse at LeMoyne College, and reportedly lives outside Rochester in Fairport, NY.


This 1973 Topps card #360 features Gene Tenace, not Joe Rudi. In the 1972 Reds-A's World Series, Tenace was a menace to the Reds with 4 home runs, 9 RBI's, and a .348 batting average. Oh yea, the A's won the series in 7-games and Tenace won the MVP award.


Not too bad when your likeness gets confused with a future Hall of Famer. That's Tim Raines' photo in this 1982 Fleer card #207.



In this 1977 Topps card #634 the Reuschel brothers names are reversed. Paul is on the right. The brothers were Cubs teammates from 1975 - 1978.




Hope you enjoyed the post.

Be well,

CinciCuse Bill



Labels:

Comments

  1. Brett AlanApril 12, 2020 at 9:37 AM

    Man, the Joe Rudi is embarrassing, with THREE A's players clearly visible, and none of them are the correct player! Tenace is in the middle, and it's Bill North to his left (to the right from our point of view). Any idea who the other one is?

    In 2017 Eric Campbell showed up on Lucas Duda's card--there's a correction that's only in the boxed complete sets, just to mess with everyone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. CinciCuse BillApril 12, 2020 at 1:20 PM

      Good stuff Bret. I don't recognize the other player. But man, those early-mid 70's A's teams sure were a powerhouse!

      Delete
  2. FujiApril 12, 2020 at 10:31 AM

    Wow. Can't believe I never noticed that Perfect Game! card. I totally remember that game... and knew that Hassey caught for Barker. Plus I also recognize Diaz. Just never put all of the pieces together.

    P.S. I just featured that 77T Reuschel brothers card on my blog yesterday, but didn't know that Topps made a mistake in labeling them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. CinciCuse BillApril 12, 2020 at 1:28 PM

      I noticed this error when I saw a 1983 Fleer card that also acknowledges the perfect game, and it shows Barker with Hassey.

      Just saw your post from yesterday. I could use more National Beer Days!

      Delete
  3. night owlApril 12, 2020 at 4:37 PM

    Did a similar themed post for April Fool's Day last year. Rodney Scott and Pete Mackanin were included, along with others:

    http://nightowlcards.blogspot.com/2019/04/wont-get-fooled-again.html

    I didn't know about the Bob Geren one, but then 1989 Traded is one of those sets that has fallen under my radar.

    ReplyDelete
  4. BoApril 12, 2020 at 5:21 PM

    My favorite is 1983 Fleer Ed Glynn. The guy pictured is actually Bud Anderson. However you can see the jersey of a player behind Anderson, just the jersey no heard, and it's Ed Glynn!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. BoApril 12, 2020 at 5:22 PM

      Also Mike Fennell died very young, of cancer in 2002.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ballplayers Turned Announcers, Actors, Writers, Etc.

  We all know of ballplayers that become announcers, actors, or writers. This post shows cards for a few notable examples, as well as a few other players with occupations that you may not be aware of. Announcers 1952 Topps card #227. Not only was Joe Garagiola a catcher for parts of nine season with four clubs, but he was also an announcer, writer, and host of numerous television shows. Joe was honored by the Baseball Hall of Fame with the Ford C. Frick Award for outstanding broadcasting accomplishments and he was named as the 2014 recipient of the Buck O'Neil Lifetime Achievement Award, presented once every three years by the Baseball Hall of Fame for positive contributions to Major League Baseball.     1965 Topps card #65. Tony Kubek played for the Yankees for nine seasons, winning the 1957 Rookie of the Year award and selected to three All-Star games. Kubek played in six World Series in the late 1950s and early 1960s, starting in 37 World Series games. Upon his retirement, Kubek
6 comments
Read more

Welcome to my first post!

Original, well-loved, cards from my youth. Rose: "I'd walk through hell in a gasoline suit to play baseball." My Story: I started collecting sports cards back in 1970 when I was about 9-yrs old. If I recall correctly, the first packs I opened in 70 and 71 contained a card of Pete Rose. Rose became my favorite player because of his hustle and desire to win, and he was one of the main cogs of the Cincinnati Reds Big Red Machine, my favorite team. (I still consider Rose to be one of the best players ever, but I have no respect for what he has done outside of the white lines) I collected a lot of cards up until mid 1975 which is when my interests changed, but I never got rid of those cards (nor were they thrown away by mom or dad, thankfully). I got back into collecting, on and off, from the mid 80's up to this day, but only baseball cards. Over the years, I realized I had a fairly decent collection of player cards from those days and started to organize my co
9 comments
Read more

4 Home Run Games

A player hitting four home runs in one game has only been achieved 18 times in MLB history. No one has done it twice. In this collection, I try to obtain cards that acknowledge this rare feat with preferably some notation on the front of the card, but if I can't find that I look for some acknowledgement on the back of the card. 1. On Memorial Day May 30, 1894 Bobby Lowe became the first MLB player to hit 4 HRs in one game when his Boston Beaneaters beat the Cincinnati Reds 20 - 11. The HRs were hit consecutively. Although this card pictures Bobby Lowe with Milwaukee of the Western Association, he made it to the majors in 1890 and spent 18 years in the majors. His best season was 1894 when he had 212 hits, 17 HRs, 115 RBIs and a .346 BA. Bobby Lowe Old Judge Reprint. 2. On July 13, 1896 Ed Delahanty became the 2nd player to hit 4 HRS in one game, 2 of which were inside-the-park. Despite this feat, his Philadelphia Phillies lost to the Chicago Colts 9 - 8. Delahanty hit over
9 comments
Read more